The snapshot: Recording a thousand words’ worth of evidence
Documenting evidence is essential to any investigation. Photography, a powerful and yet convenient form of documentation, allows an investigator to capture the essence of a scene and record large or immovable objects at the scene. Clearly, using photography in long-term care (LTC) internal investigations is a preferred form of documentation.
Recently, television shows such as CSI have brought the term forensic into the public vernacular. The word forensic is defined as “relating to, used in, or appropriate for courts of law or for public discussion or argumentation” (American Heritage College Dictionary, 4th ed.).
Forensic photographers learn and perfect principles and skills for obtaining legally sufficient photographs of scenes and evidence. A good working knowledge of the principles of forensic photography will benefit the LTC detective, especially if investigative results are ever brought to arbitration or courts of law. Even without advanced formal training, LTC investigators who possess basic photographic knowledge and follow simple guidelines can enhance efforts to obtain appropriate and useful photographs for internal inquiries.
State survey agencies already have the green light for use of photography during investigations. In September 2006, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) issued some basic principles for state survey agencies to follow when using photography. While CMS was clear that photography of the survey process is not required, it said certain principles should be followed if it is used:
Request written permission before photographing a resident.
Get a complete set of photographs.
Document the photographs.
These principles integrate well with the principles of investigative protocol as laid out in this two-part series, which will:
Explore the use of photography during investigations.
Describe ways to document photographic evidence.
Offer practical advice for selecting effective, basic, inexpensive equipment; taking photographs of the residents and scene; and retaining photographic records.
Cautions When Taking Photographs
Photographs may help with understanding an event, clarifying the facts, and drawing a conclusion. Use them with caution, though. Clearly, regulations and common sense require resident respect and protection. The investigator must be sensitive to the resident’s feelings and privacy when photographing the scene. Remember, the facility is the resident’s home and it, along with personal belongings, must be respected. If the resident has an injury, written permission must be obtained from the resident, family member, or surrogate before taking personal photographs of the resident’s body. These and other issues regarding photographs should have written policies that address the following issues:
When to use photography during an investigation;
What protocols, qualifications and training are required to take photographs during an investigation;
When family member or surrogate permission is required;
How to handle and document a refusal by a resident, family member, or surrogate to allow photographs to be taken; and
What protocols should be used when photographing parts of a resident’s body during an investigation.
Underlying the need to request resident permission before taking photographs are two important principles: resident rights and informed consent. As participants in the Medicare and Medicaid programs, LTC facilities are required to ensure that resident rights are protected. Even though our goal in performing the inquiry is to help and serve the resident, we must do this while considering the right to privacy and respect.
The exact standards necessary to satisfy informed consent for taking photographs are beyond the scope of this article. Consult your facility’s legal counsel before establishing the aforementioned policies and procedures.
Reasons to Use Photographs
The following are a few of the powerful ways photographs can enhance the understanding of evidence:
Photographs of the scene will allow the investigator to understand the context in which the event occurred, including furniture location, safety conditions in the area, lighting, and any unusual circumstances present, e.g., inappropriate use of equipment or placement of furniture.
Photographs of injuries can indicate the severity of the injury and suggest how the injury was created; e.g., an open hand slap, or a bruise that was present before the event.
Photographs can reveal evidence previously overlooked at a scene, e.g., a wall clock documenting time, presence of a pen (left by a nurse) on an end table.
Photographs, taken using proper procedures and depicting the scene accurately, could become key evidence in a future legal or disciplinary case.
Investigations generated within healthcare facilities are usually designed to establish compliance with internal controls and state and federal regulations, as well as to identify liability. Documenting such events with properly taken and secured photographs enhances the facility’s professionalism and helps memorialize the actual event in a manner that is, in many cases, superior to other forms of evidence, including witness statements.
A wide variety of photographic equipment is, of course, available in all ranges of performance and cost. Digital equipment is the most cost-effective for this purpose and requires the least amount of training to operate competently; the camera user is able to review the captured image immediately, unlike print film that must be developed. Additionally, digital images are held on space-saving memory cards or disks.
Equipment capable of capturing close-up and wide-angle images is required. Consider the specific needs of your organization and consult with legal counsel to determine the image size required if the photographs were used in legal proceedings; these needs will determine the type of camera and number of megapixels required. Discuss these requirements with a photograpy store expert before purchasing.
A significant factor affecting equipment cost is its capacity to produce clear, enlarged images; equipment that allows for significant high-resolution enlargement is more expensive. Remember, too, that not all cameras are able to take close-up shots, even though they have a “zoom” lens.
Besides the camera, the equipment bag should include several photographic documentation tools:
Reference measure. When-ever evidence is recorded, the photographer must include a scale in one set of the photos to reference the subject’s actual size. The following are examples of references measures:
The gray Photo Evidence Ruler (6″) works well for evidence photography (figure 1).
The ABFO (American Board of Forensic Odontology) Photomacrographic Scale measures injuries (figure 2).
The gray Adhesive Photo Evidence Scale is excellent when photographing bruises (figure 3).
The Folding Evidence Scale (36″, flexible) has bold black numbers on a yellow background. It stands out extremely well in either black-and-white or color photographs (figure 4).
Photo Evidence Rulers
ABFO Photomacrographic Scale
Adhesive Photo Evidence Scale
Folding Evidence Scale
File folder. This should have a pocket to hold photographs or storage devices.
Extra memory card. A backup should be on hand in case the primary card fails.
Physical evidence record (photo log). This form is used in The Amo Group (TAG) Four Phase Model for Investigations and is the preferred way to document photographs. More on this model can be found in Investigations in Long-Term Care Facilities: Implementing a Standardized Model by Niki L. Rowe and Michael Amo (Vendome Group, LLC, 2006). A facility may choose its own method of logging, however, always note the photograph’s description, who took the photograph, when was it taken, and its relevancy to the investigation. The investigator should also have access to a photo printer or possibly software for merging photos into the investigation report.
After obtaining equipment, the investigator needs training in its ongoing use and care. Modern equipment requires little or no photographic experience, allowing facility staff members with a minimum of training to capture appropriate images for LTC investigations. For example, most digital cameras today are equipped with auto-flash and auto-focus features; the user only needs to select the expanse of the image using the zoom feature.
By providing your chosen investigators with a short overview on when and how to take photos, you can be confident they will be able to handle all your facility’s investigative needs. Plan regular practice sessions to maintain appropriate skills.
Part two of this article, examining the photographic process in detail, will appear in a future issue.
Michael Amo, MS, CNHA, is Founder of and a Principal in the healthcare consulting firm The Amo Group, LLC, created to help LTC organizations and facilities implement improvement strategies regarding abuse prevention and prohibition
Kenneth T. Jones currently serves as the Undersheriff in the Orange County (New York) Sheriff’s Office and has taught Criminal Investigation at SUNY Sullivan for 20 years. He is retired from the New York State Police, where he served in a Forensic Crime Scene Unit and attended more than 100 homicide scenes in addition to other crime scenes. He is an adviser to The Amo Group, providing a forensic investigation overview to issues within LTC facilities
Niki Lee Rowe, MA, CALA, LMHC, is a Principal in The Amo Group. She is licensed in the state of New York as a mental health counselor and is a nationally certified assisted living administrator who has been administrator for locked Alzheimer’s facilities and innovative facilities for the severely mentally ill
To send your comments to the authors and editors, e-mail firstname.lastname@example.org.
Topics: Articles , Risk Management